Second Chance Girl by Susan Mallery

October 5, 2017 Book Reviews 2 ★★★★

Second Chance Girl by Susan MallerySecond Chance Girl Series: Happily Inc. #2
on September 26, 2017
Pages: 384
Purchase: Amazon
Add to Goodreads

Also in this series: Why Not Tonight

Mathias Mitchell's easy smile hides a world of hurt. After the worst kind of family betrayal, he moves to Happily Inc., California—the wedding destination town supplies a steady stream of bridesmaids, perfect for his "no promises, no pain" lifestyle. Yet he can't stop watching for his beautiful, elusive neighbor on the animal preserve behind their homes.

Gamekeeper Carol Lund knows she's not special enough to attract an alpha male like Mathias, so his offer to help her adopt a herd for her lonely giraffe is surprising—and his determined seduction, even more so. But just as she finally welcomes him into her bed, his careless actions crush her heart. Will she give him a second chance to prove she'll always come first in his heart?

I received a review copy of this book from the publisher.


If you’ve read the later Fool’s Gold books and/or You Say It First, the first Happily, Inc. book, you already know a little about Mathias Mitchell and his brothers… and if you don’t, you’ll get the necessary backstory in this book. My heart really went out to Mathias, who has been wounded twice by his artist father’s cruelty, in the two things that matter most to him: his art, and his relationship with his not-actually-twin brother Ronan. Coupled with the dysfunctional Mitchell family dynamics, this has left Mathias determined never to get seriously involved or fall in love. He’s a player, enjoying a series of one- or two-night stands with bridesmaids in town for destination weddings.

But behind the careless playboy exterior is a lonely, wounded, but fundamentally good man who is inexplicably attracted by his friendly neighbor Carole–and her giraffe, Milly. Carol runs the animal preserve across the road from Mathias’s house. She’s warm, softhearted, loyal, and absolutely dedicated to her animals. She’s also attracted to Mathias, but she does her best to keep their relationship to “just friends”… because why would a gorgeous, talented guy like Mathias ever be interested in ordinary, boring her? Especially for the long term, because as she knows — as the whole town knows — Mathias doesn’t do long term.

A lovable but accident-prone beagle, a campaign to buy companions for Milly, and a family wedding — Mathias’s brother Del and his fiance Maya (Thrill Me) add both complications and fun, and a just-barely-secondary romance featuring Carol’s sister and a duke rounds out this pleasing, warmhearted romance. There’s humor and real emotion and that touch of whimsy that characterizes some of Mallery’s romances.

My heart really went out to Mathias, who has had too much rejection in his life. Carol’s insecurities about her own attractiveness are completely relatable; her common sense and empathy make her a very appealing heroine. I also enjoyed the secondary romance, though I thought each relationship deserved its own book. And I love Millie and the way Carol’s friends and family rally to buy the lonely giraffe a herd.

While I don’t yet have quite the same affection for the town of Happily, Inc. that I do for Fool’s Gold, the ties between the two (in the form of the Mitchell brothers) are giving me time to settle in and get to know and like Mallery’s newest setting. I’m already looking forward to the next installment, and hoping it finally brings some badly-needed resolution to the last, most tortured brother, Ronan.


About Susan Mallery

With more than 25 million books sold worldwide, New York Times bestselling author Susan Mallery is known for creating characters who feel as real as the folks next door, and for putting them into emotional, often funny situations readers recognize from their own lives. Susan’s books have made Booklist’s Top 10 Romances list in four out of five consecutive years. RT Book Reviews says, “When it comes to heartfelt contemporary romance, Mallery is in a class by herself.” With her popular, ongoing Fool’s Gold series, Susan has reached new heights on the bestsellers lists and has won the hearts of countless new fans.

Susan grew up in southern California, moved so many times that her friends stopped writing her address in pen, and now has settled in Seattle with her husband and the most delightfully spoiled little dog who ever lived.

Reading this book contributed to these challenges:

  • Tackle Your TBR Read-a-thon 2017

2 Responses to “Second Chance Girl by Susan Mallery”